The recent USA Today opinion column by Steny Hoyer and Nancy Pelosi reeks of double standards.
So people who are opposed to any kind of socialist health coverage reforms who attend town hall meetings to express their opposition to their Congressthings are “un-American.” But when people who were disgusted with Bush and GOP policies (like starting wars) protested quite loudly for a good 8 years, it was deemed (correctly, for the most part) by Democratic politicians to be an exercise in the right to free speech.
The charge that these health care protesters are being ‘put up to it’ by the Republican and Libertarian parties is both hypocritical and inaccurate.
First, the anti-Bush protesters were just as much put up to it as these anti-Obama protesters are; that is, they were already strongly opposed to the Bush policies and the Democratic (and sometimes Libertarian) Party helped organize and focus their opposition in the form of protests and speaking out at events held by Republican politicians. What’s the difference?
Second, there is nothing at all wrong with an organization such as a political party organizing its members to ‘ambush’ politicians by showing up in force and demanding they answer tough questions. That’s one of the things for which political parties exist. As economies progress, the division of labor results in increasing specialization in order to use resources ever more efficiently, thus creating wealth. Some people (political party staff) specialize in identifying opportunities to protest a policy they disagree with and organizing people who agree with them to get out there and raise hell. So people who genuinely disagree with a policy strongly enough to protest against it but don’t have time to identify opportunities and organize their friends simply join political parties or interest groups that e-mail them the latest plans for grassroots protests and then head on over after work.
Sounds like Steny and Nancy are just a little too thin-skinned for a taste of what their own people have been doing to the GOP for the past 8 years.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!